Sunday, May 17, 2015
The Rabbit Hole of Analysis
I read a lot of graphic novels, or I used to, anyway I really like them, and I think their authors are so talented. What I think is the most interesting about them is how the compare to other books, if you read a book for class there is really only so much you can read into it without falling down the rabbit hole, but with a graphic novel so much thought goes into ever picture and word, because the dialog and writing have to be snappy to fit in a comic style layout, and you can really tell from the pictures the background and focus of the author. There is so much perspective to uncover in a graphic novel or a comic book (if you want to go down that road please check out the article Superheros on my other blog). It is so important to have both imagery and words to explain to us a situation, that is why we give children picture books, to explain to them things they do not have the experience to understand. That is why Maus is so great, it makes us feel a part of something that we could not previously understand. Not that we could understand the experience of being in the Holocaust, or being the child of two survivors in two short books (even if they are amazing), but at least we can get closer to understanding, and that is what art and writing are all about.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree that graphic novels have so much behind both pictures and words. Whether or not it has a message behind each image and piece of writing, the visuals paired /with/ these words create a new kind of explanation that would be different with either standing on their own. Reading Maus especially has opened up my eyes to this, as I've heard many people sharing their thoughts on these drawings and excerpts, taking them from a different angle than I initially had. Then again, of course, that's the case for any work of writing or art, and that perspective is also one of the great things about it. Push personal interpretations aside, the idea that more ways of executing the ideas better helps somebody understand a given situation is certainly true; while it may vary on how much, it still happens.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree as well with Zoe. When I read a book about a controversial issue I am very impressed and I try my best to sympathize with people who experienced something just like the holocaust. Unfortunately, I can't experience as much emotional connection to a story as I can to a graphic novel. The graphic novel I can appreciate too because in my opinion more work went into it.
ReplyDelete